Prediction for the 2021 Yankee Season

It’s that time of year — opening day this afternoon — and it is in the 40’s (high maybe 50 degrees) and overcast. In other words people are going to freeze their ass off who are there in person. forecast for the season: sunny skies, 100+ wins, and first place in the East. This despite the ton of question (?) marks that surround this team. Full, final prediction for the 2021 season at the bottom of this article.

The Question (?) Marks

The Yankees are loaded with question marks:

  1. Will Gleyber Torres improve his defense at shortstop to become decent there? If Gleyber continues poor play at short, where do you put him? LeMahieu is at 2nd.
  2. Will Gary Sanchez be able to revive his career and become again one of the best catchers in baseball, or is he careening out of the Major Leagues?
  3. What to do with Miguel Andujar who can hit hit hit but can’t field at 3rd well.
  4. Will Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton stay healthy for a full season?
  5. Will Cory Kluber, Jameson Taillon, and/or Luis Severino come back from arm injuries and be dominant again?
  6. Is Aroldis Chapman getting old and no longer reliable in the playoffs?
  7. Will Clint Frazier finally break through and put in a full, good season in left. Versus having the job taken away for the playoffs by Brett Gardner again?

A lot of question marks. Seven.

The Starting Staff

The starting staff is what makes this Yankee team look like a 105-win team. If all works out. Even if Kluber and Taillon and Severino fail — the Yankees still have:

  1. Gerrit Cole — ace
  2. Domingo German — scouts are saying he has the #2 stuff on the staff in the Spring — better than Kluber or Taillon
  3. Jordan Montgomery — Reminds me of a young Andy Pettitte (not only 6’5 lefty with confidence & command but the way NY media has given him little mind despite so many strong starts as a rookie and last year, his comeback yr — like Pettitte was disregarded in 1995). Brian Cashman waxed poetic about Monty during a radio interview in December, especially pointing out how well he did in the playoff game vs Tampa. I predict a 14-7 season for Monty, or better.
The 6’5 lefty Jordan Montgomery came up big in a crucial playoff game vs Tampa last season.

The Yanks also have Deivi Garcia and Clarke Schmidt in the wings.

  • Deivi Garcia: Deivi got beat up in his last start of the Spring, which had him sent to the minors. He gave up a homer in the 1st. 3 singles in the 2nd, a single and a homer in the 3rd, a walk to lead off the 4th and he was gone. 3.0 innings, 7 hits allowed, 4 runs. Still had a 3.86 ERA for the Spring. Deivi has movement on his pitches and is an old-fashioned, clever pitcher — pitching to contact — but I’m not sure of his future; whether he’ll be a mediocre major league pitcher or the next Pedro Martinez. I hope I’m surprised and he’s the latter.

Masahiro Tanaka is back in Japan, and James Paxton is back on Seattle (where I predict he will have a great year). Tanaka did not look good in the playoff game last year. Paxton pitched great in NY when healthy. If only the two of them pitched in the 2020 playoffs like they did in 2019…

For 2021 — if the Yanks get good pitching from one of the 3 comeback ‘ace’s — their starting staff will be excellent; if they get good pitching from 2, their starting staff will be awesome.

The Bullpen

I worry that Aroldis Chapman isn’t too old to be effective as a closer in the playoffs anymore. He’s going to be 33 this year, has had some failures in recent years (although some of it due to Houston knowing what pitch was coming), and his fastball wasn’t as fast last year.

The Yanks have Zack Britton as the setup and insurance closer, but he’s out til June at the earliest after elbow surgery. Who knows how long it will take for him to be effective again.

Chad Green is still in the pen, as is Jonathan Loaisiga, Justin Wilson (currently out with a shoulder injury that an MRI said was just soreness), Darren O’Day, Michael King, and lefty Lucas Luetge.

But the one I’m most hopeful for is Nick Nelson — with the 98 MPH fastball and “special” change up. More importantly, manager Aaron Boone is excited about Nelson, which makes me excited. Said Boone after a Spring training game, “”He was able to get some key outs and some big swings and misses even when he was behind in the count,” the skipper said. “He made a couple pitches when he needed to and the trust in that changeup to go along with that high 90s fastball is something we really like. I feel like he continues to grow and polish a little bit. He’s definitely someone we are excited about.”

Overall — the Yankees bullpen could be awesome if Nelson is as good as hoped and Britton returns strong, and Chapman can keep bringing it another year at 33.


It’s not hard to predict another bad year for Gary Sanchez. He started out well in the Spring, with a just-hit-the-ball-where-it’s-pitched attitude, but by the end was in a major slump striking out all over the place. Backup Kyle Higashioka looked good last year.

Robinson Chirinos starts the year in the minors. I predict Sanchez will slump and Chirinos will be handling a bulk of the catching, with Higashioka by June. I hope I’m wrong and Sanchez does well.

The Infield

Gleyber Torres made some great plays in the field at the end of Spring training so there is hope there for his defense.

And he hit some shots. A good Gleyber — offensively and defensively — is a key to a successful year for the Yanks.

Luke Voit is out with a torn meniscus but should return by July. In his stead, the Yanks have Jay Bruce, and DJ LeMahieu — last year’s batting title winner — can play some 1st. Would be great if Miguel Andujar could learn the position.

Have no reason to believe Gio Urshela won’t continue to be a good spray hitter — hitting ball to all fields — and playing Graig Nettles – esq defense. When he was in the minors in the Cleveland organization Urshela had a similar ranking to Clint Frazier — so Urshela’s talent did not come out of nowhere.

Derek Dietrich starts the season in the minor leagues; I predict he will be up on the big club at some point and play some good ball for NY. If past seasons are an indicator, the Yanks will make a trade for infielders as they go along, if Dietrich doesn’t cut it.


All of New York are waiting to see if Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton can stay healthy for a majority of the year — it would be the first time. I fully expect this to happen and am hoping for a big year from both. And Clint Frazier is scheduled to be the full-time left fielder; he looked good last year until a late season slump.

Giancarlo Stanton was healthy and ON FIRE in Game 1 of the Tampa playoff series last year.

Aaron Hicks in center — high OBP and good fielder — although last year after Tommy John surgery he was throwing lollipops back into the infield. His arm strength will be something to watch.

And Brett Gardner as back as outfield reserve. He had a .354 OPB last year despite a .223 batting average, and can still give you Gold Glove Defense.

Overall Prediction

I’m going to go out on a Big limb and predict the Yanks will win 105 games this year and take 1st place in the Division. Tampa unloaded two of their best pitchers, which should tame their win total a bit.

I predict the Yanks make it to, and win, the World Series — although the playoffs are always a roll-the-dice crapshoot.

I think the Yankee starting staff will hold up and be at times awesome, and their bullpen will be good, and Judge and Stanton and Gleyber and LeMahieu will power an awesome offense. Maybe they’ll win 102 games; anything less than 98 will be a disappointment.

Disclaimer: I am an optimist.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.